Mouse Triumphs on the Moon

Modest Mouse
The Moon and Antarctica

CD review by Claude Iosso

When I heard Modest Mouse had signed with a major label, I wondered if the band would moderate its quirky sound. With keening guitar melodies and Isaac Brock’s desperate vocals, the Issaquah trio had won a devoted local following since its 1996 debut EP, Interstate 8 (Up). Fans will be glad to know that the band has maintained its angry charm without a lick of compromise on The Moon and Antarctica (Epic).

Brock spews with less testosterone than he did on the last release of new material, 1997’s The Lonesome Crowded West (Up), but new hooks leap from his guitar and his isolationist, sometimes apocalyptic view of the world is as weird as ever.

The bleakness of Brock’s lyrics is belied by the album’s rich texture and joyous melodies. Modest Mouse has employed violins and synthesizers before, but they seem to knit into the songs better on Moon and Antarctica. Drummer Jeremiah Green and bassist Eric Judy are rock-solid as they hold the compositions together through shifting rhythms.

There are pretty songs such as "3rd Planet," "Gravity Rides Everything" and "Paper Thin Walls" that feature Brock’s delectable cascades of notes. There are urgent and mesmerizing dark ones, including "Dark Center of the Universe," "A Different City" and "Alone Down There."

A highlight for me is a winning funk number, "Tiny Cities Made of Ashes." I bobbed my head back and forth to the rhythmic, absurdist lyrics: "So we’re drinkin drinkin drinkin coca-coca-cola, I can feel it rollin right on down, Oh right on down my throat." Modest Mouse even dips into the ambient trend with the nine-minute epic "The Stars Are Projectors."

MM moves away from the slow-and-sweet/fast-and-furious song structure that has marked most of its best known tunes, which makes Moon and Antarctica easier to listen to than Lonesome Crowded West was. However, Brock’s lyrics, which always resonated despite only skating on the edge of comprehensibility, win him the crown as the dark prince of desolation.

"I wanna live in a city with no friends or family, I’m gonna look out the window of my color t.v., I wanna remember to remember to forget you forgot me," he cries in "A Different City." In "3rd Planet," Brock sings, "Everything that keeps me together is falling apart, I’ve got this thing that I consider my only art of fucking people over." The vein of self-hatred continues in "Dark Center of the Universe"-- "Well it took a lot of work to be the ass that I am, and I’m really damn sure that anyone can equally easily fuck you over."

It’s hard to say whether the nation will embrace the clever contrarians from Issaquah, but they’ve done their part with a tasty slice of rock’n’roll on Moon and Antarctica. This is no sellout, though it should sell out...

Modest Mouse in the Class of 2000

Claude Iosso's 1997 profile of Modest Mouse

Claude Iosso's review of The Lonesome Crowded West

Visit the premier Modest Mouse Fan Site

Also at Pandomag.com

A Techno Devil Takes it to the Next Level
Percussionist Matt Walker talks about Cupcakes, rocket fuel, and the good old days in Filter and Smashing Pumpkins, by Gail Worley

Pink Floyd Marries Blue Dorothy
On July 3, at 11 pm (ET), Turner Classic Movies will broadcast The Wizard of Oz synchronized with Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon. Two years ago, Captain Spaulding sorted all of this out for you in Hooray For Me!

WHAT'S THE SOUND OF WHITE MEN RAPPING?
J. Kim takes on Kid Rock and Eminem saying: "While racism disgusts me, the history of whites and men in the United States also disgusts me;" in the Divine Miss K

The Flaming Lips' Flying Audiophile Circus
"Talking with Wayne Coyne about the band's evolution is like being guided through a minefield of entertainment possibilities" says Brian Charest

Radiohead Are Just Genesis With A Distortion Pedal
Radiohead Mockery! Piper Down Naughtiness! Stereolab Slammed! The Drugs Go Off! Shannon Stephens Oils Up! Get Dirty With KTL 86...

JOHN CUSACK TAKES THE LAST TRAIN TO GUYVILLE
High Fidelity gets high marks from Captain Spaulding in
Hooray For Me!

Cerys Matthews, Siren of Catatonia
Is this fetching femme the next Britstar in line for huge US adoration? Come and see, says Reef Valmont